Wednesday, October 19, 2011

"Great minds discuss ideas. Average minds discuss events. Small minds discuss people." Eleanor Roosevelt

Eleanor Roosevelt regarded the Universal Declaration as her greatest accomplishment.

Eleanor Roosevelt

"Where, after all, do universal human rights begin? In small places, close to home - so close and so small that they cannot be seen on any maps of the world. Yet they are the world of the individual person; the neighborhood he lives in; the school or college he attends; the factory, farm, or office where he works. Such are the places where every man, woman, and child seeks equal justice, equal opportunity, equal dignity without discrimination. Unless these rights have meaning there, they have little meaning anywhere. Without concerted citizen action to uphold them close to home, we shall look in vain for progress in the larger world."

Eleanor Roosevelt

 

Although she had already won international respect and admiration in her role as First Lady to President Franklin D. Roosevelt, Eleanor Roosevelt’s work on the Universal Declaration of Human Rights would become her greatest legacy. She was without doubt, the most influential member of the UN’s Commission on Human Rights.

Unlike most other members of the Commission, Mrs. Roosevelt was neither a scholar nor an expert on international law. Her enthusiasm for her work at the United Nations was rooted in her humanitarian convictions and her steady faith in human dignity and worth. Although she often joked that she was out of place among so many academics and jurists, her intellect and compassion were great assets, and proved to be of crucial importance in the composition of a direct and straightforward Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

With characteristic modesty, Eleanor Roosevelt considered her position on the Commission to be one of ambassador for the common man and woman: "I used to tell my husband that, if he could make me understand something, it would be clear to all other people in the country, and perhaps that will be my real value on this drafting commission!"

The delegates to the Commission on Human Rights elected Eleanor Roosevelt their Chairperson. Like so many individuals throughout the world, the delegates recognized Eleanor Roosevelt’s unparalleled humanitarian convictions. During her tenure in the White House she had assisted her physically disabled husband in political matters, serving as his "eyes and ears," traveling throughout the U.S. to gauge the mood of the people. Through this work, she became widely esteemed as a person who both understood and felt the plight of the common man and woman.

Even prior to her years in the White House, Eleanor Roosevelt was actively engaged in politics and advocacy on the local and national level. She was an astute, accomplished, and intelligent woman, thoroughly familiar with the world of political negotiation. Just as she had served as a liaison of sorts between the President and his constituency, so she acted as a liaison between the Commission and the hopes of humanity. She may have lacked certain factual knowledge, but she had a keen sense of what the average person expected out of life - what men, women and children needed to flourish as individuals.

Her common sense approach, constant optimism and boundless energy were integral to the smooth facilitation of meetings. On any given issue, her colloquial style and good humor were engaged not only to win over the majority of delegates who generally supported a particular U.S. position, but to confound those who opposed it. A New York Times reporter who was present at the Commission meetings wrote of the power Mrs. Roosevelt’s personality had over certain unreasonable diplomats:

The Russians seem to have met their match in Mrs. Roosevelt. The proceedings sometimes turn into a long vitriolic attack on the U.S. when she is not present. These attacks, however, generally denigrate into flurries in the face of her calm and undisturbed but often pointed replies.

If Mrs. Roosevelt made one sort of impression with her familiar style, she made another with her commitment to produce a universally accepted, "living" declaration. She was recognized as a tireless worker, stating triumphantly at one point, "I drive hard and when I get home I will be tired! The men on the Commission will be also!" Many of the delegates found this aspect of her personality less agreeable than her charm. One went so far as to suggest that his own human rights were violated by the length of the meetings!

Envisioning a declaration with enduring principles that would be perpetually recognized by all nations, she was a strong advocate of true universality within the Declaration. She was adamant that different conceptions of human rights be deliberated during the UDHR’s composition:

We wanted as many nations as possible to accept the fact that men, for one reason or another, were born free and equal in dignity and rights, that they were endowed with reason and conscience, and should act toward one another in a spirit of brotherhood. The way to do that was to find words that everyone would accept.

Eleanor Roosevelt’s personal sense of accomplishment with the finished Declaration was unparalleled in her life. Her speech before the General Assembly as she submitted the Declaration for review demonstrates the historical significance she placed upon its adoption:

We stand today at the threshold of a great event both in the life of the United Nations and in the life of mankind. This declaration may well become the international Magna Carta for all men everywhere. We hope its proclamation by the General Assembly will be an event comparable to the proclamation in 1789 [of the French Declaration of the Rights of Man], the adoption of the Bill of Rights by the people of the U.S., and the adoption of comparable declarations at different times in other countries...

Eleanor Roosevelt’s concern for humanity made her the driving force behind the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Her leadership of the Commission on Human Rights led to the composition of a Declaration that has endured as a universally accepted standard of achievement for all nations. As our respect for and understanding of the Universal Declaration has grown, so too has our gratitude and admiration for this modest woman who passionately pursued what she imagined would become a cornerstone in the struggle for human rights and fundamental freedoms for everyone - everywhere.

She lived her life in the center of what many would regard the Twentieth Century’s most consequential events, the Great Depression, World War II, the establishment of the United Nations and the adoption of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. She confronted both opportunity and adversity with a sense of optimism and determination. A former Democratic presidential candidate, Adlai Stevenson, once said of Eleanor Roosevelt, "She would rather light a candle than curse the darkness."


Eleanor Roosevelt on Human Rights:

Universal Declaration of Human Rights (December 10, 1948) United Nations.
The Universal Declaration is the primary international articulation of the fundamental and inalienable rights of all members of the human family. It represents the first comprehensive agreement among nations as to the specific rights and freedoms of all human beings. The Declaration has become a cornerstone of customary international law, binding all governments to its principles.

Human Rights and Human Freedom: An American View (1946) Eleanor Roosevelt
As a member of the United States delegation to the United Nations General Assembly, Mrs. Roosevelt debates Andrei Vishinsky, chief Soviet delegate, over the proposed amendment that no propaganda should be permitted in refugee camps against the interests of the United Nations or its members. The success of her argument, based on the idea that such an amendment would violate human rights by restricting freedom of speech and expression, strengthened Mrs. Roosevelt’s position as a leading voice in the international defense of human rights.

The Promise of Human Rights (April 1948) Eleanor Roosevelt.
This article, from the journal Foreign Affairs, provides a brief history of the Commission on Human Rights and its efforts to write a draft international Bill of Human Rights, including a Declaration and a Convention. Mrs. Roosevelt discusses both documents, including the articles she thinks are of vital importance, and her views on the Commission’s work in general.

Making Human Rights Come Alive (1949) Eleanor Roosevelt.
This speech to the Second National Conference on UNESCO reflects on the Universal Declaration and the problems that had to be overcome in writing a truly international document. Mrs. Roosevelt cites the difficulties in searching for appropriate wording and precedents in law and especially in bridging the gaps between cultures.

Statement on Draft Covenant on Human Rights (1951) Eleanor Roosevelt.
The American delegation proposes that the Draft Covenant be divided into two separate documents of equal importance to be considered for adoption simultaneously; one for civil and political rights and the other for economic, social, and cultural rights. Mrs. Roosevelt argues that differences in terms of the time, methods and machinery needed to implement the various provisions make such a division a practical step.

On the Draft Convention on Political Rights of Women (1953) Eleanor Roosevelt.
Discussing the specific articles of the Convention, Mrs. Roosevelt argues that the objectives of the United Nations are not only to encourage equal political rights for women in all countries, but also to ensure that women fully participate in directing the policy making of their governments.

In Your Hands (March 27, 1958) Eleanor Roosevelt. 
Presenting a "guide to community action" on the eve of the Universal Declaration’s Tenth Anniversary, Mrs. Roosevelt declares that "the destiny of human rights is in the hands of all our citizens in all our communities." She urges people to improve human rights conditions "in small places, close to home" as the first step towards global progress.

Adoption of the Declaration of Human Rights (December 9, 1948) Eleanor Roosevelt


Monday, October 17, 2011

There Are Lies, Damned lies, and Statistics: Proof in Wage & Hour Class Actions

The illusion of truth found in statistics is that numbers not only point at truth, they actually touch it.  When I was a boy growing up in the cornfields of Southern Illinois, my two mentor grandfathers would take me rabbit hunting.  They would put me in middle as the three of us walked in a line down the rows of winter stubble in the harvested field.  If we scared up a rabbit, and the two of them missed both left and right, they proclaimed by an average of their two missed shots, I had hit the rabbit.  Statistically, that I had not even pulled the trigger made no difference, though we at no rabbit for dinner that night.

So here’s the philosophical question:  if 59,000 employees do not take their meal or lunch breaks, but no one sees or hears a manager tell them to forego their breaks, does the missed break really happen?  Actually, the question is legal as well, and has practical consequences.  The employees would like to use statistical proof to make their case.  The proof goes like this:  if the employer’s time records show an unexpectedly high incidence of missed breaks so far outside the “standard deviation” expected by random chance, then can we conclude that another factor was operating to produce the missed breaks?  And . . . is that other “factor” the culture and direction of management? 

Wednesday, October 12, 2011

Place a Brain in the Brainstorm. Slugs can acquire new mugs, & become innovative pugs.

The following article is a reprint:  

HBR Blog Network (Harvard Business Review)

JEFF DYER AND HAL GREGERSEN

Jeff Dyer is the Horace Beesley Professor of Strategy at the Marriott School, Brigham Young University; Hal Gregersen is a professor of leadership at INSEAD; They are the authors of the The Innovator’s DNA.

Learn How to Think Different(ly)

10:24 AM Tuesday September 27, 2011 
by Jeff Dyer and Hal Gregersen 

In the Economist review of our book, The Innovator's DNA, the reviewer wondered whether genius-level innovators such as Marc Benioff, Jeff Bezos, and Steve Jobs challenge the idea that working adults can really learn how to think differently and become innovators.

We don't think so. Remember, it was Steve Jobs who jump-started the now-famous "Think Different" advertising campaign as a way to inspire consumers and recharge Apple's innovation efforts. It worked. Reflecting back on the campaign, Jobs said "The whole purpose of the 'Think Different' campaign was that people had forgotten what Apple stood for, including the employees." And the best way to tell people what Apple stood for was to tell them who the company's heroes were. The campaign reminded everyone — consumers and employees alike — that the "crazy ones...see things differently."

Reams of relevant research (including our own) proves Jobs right. Innovators excel at connecting the unconnected. They engage in associational thinking. At Apple (or at any innovative company), they take a little bit of this, sprinkle in a little bit of that and that and that to churn out market-busting ideas such as iTunes, and the iPod, iPhone, and iPad (along with a few market disasters like the G4 Cube computer).

But neither Steve Jobs nor Apple nor any other high-profile innovator or company has a corner on the think-different market. In fact, our study of over 5,000 entrepreneurs and executives shows the opposite: almost anyone who consistently makes the effort to think different can think different.

Monday, October 10, 2011

Random Quotes about Law and Lawyers.

I don't want to know what the law is, I want to know who the judge is.

Roy M. Cohn

 

 

Law is mind without reason.

Aristotle -- Greek critic, philosopher, physicist, & zoologist

 

 

Lawyer: One skilled in circumvention of the law.

Ambrose Bierce

 

 

Nothing is illegal if one hundred well-placed business men decide to do it.

Andrew Young

 

 

Make crime pay. Become a Lawyer

Will Rogers

 

 

Juries scare me. I don't want to put my faith in 12 people who weren't smart enough to get out of jury duty.

Monica Piper

 

 

There are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies and statistics.

Benjamin Disraeli

 

 

I don't want any yes men around me. I want everyone to tell me the truth - even if it costs him his job.

Samuel Goldwyn

Social Network Postings Are Likely Discoverable in Litigation.

As Chair of the Orange County Bar Association Labor & Employment Law Section, I oversee monthly topic presentations for our members.  This month [10/10/11] the topic was using Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn and other social media postings as evidence.  I've written on this subject in my previous blog entries.  The bottom line:  Courts are tending to allow discovery of postings if the targeted posts are described in such a way as to be relevant to an issue in the case.  

I've also written about the administrative rulings of the NLRB (National Labor Relations Board).  These rulings, applicable to both union and non-union employers, prevent employers from punishing employees who engage in "concerted activity" to address grievances concerning the "terms and conditions of employment."  Bottom line:  even strongly worded language that a manager could consider insulting or insubordinate will be protected if it addresses a workplace condition or management behavior, and could lead to organized labor efforts to address the condition.  However, there are two considerations:  Is the communication among co-workers?  If not, the "concerted acivity" cannot apply.  Secondly, is the subject of the posting on point with "terms and conditions?"  If employees attack management without reference to addressing a term or condition of work, the "concerted activity" cannot apply. 

So, terminating an employee engaged in a "concerted activity" by his or her posting could very well trigger a lawsuit for "wrongful termination in violation of public policy" based on the National Labor Relations Act even if the employer obtained access to the posting legally.  [The "Store Communications Act (SCA) may be implicated by an unauthorized access by an employer of an employee's electronically stored information on a third party server.]

 

Friday, October 07, 2011

Real Unemployment Is 16.5%

Quote from NPR news today:

-- If the Labor Department were to measure unemployment more broadly — counting discouraged workers who have stopped looking and part-timers who want full-time work — the jobless rate would be 16.5 percent. That rate has been rising since the recent low of 15.8 percent in May.

Frank Pray  

Employee Rights Attorney
949-251-1006 Office
949-637-3360 Cell

L.A. Superior Court Pilot Program Settles Employment Law Cases.

Of the cases heard at the Stanley Mosk Courthouse in downtown L.A., about  1/3 are employment related cases according to L.A. Superior Court Judge William F. Highberger.  Judge Highberger helped create a pilot settlement program for these cases, and 135 of them were ordered into a “voluntary” “Civil Refereee Assisted Settlement Hearing” program between September 19, 2011 and September 23, 2011.  The result:  46 settlements in one week. 

The program is run with the use of two experienced employment lawyers assigned to the case, one from the plaintiff’s bar, and one from the defense.  The reason the process worked seems to be the level of expertise of the two attorney mediators and the confidence of the litigants that they are getting real world reliable advice on how to see the case. 

The program, while “compelled” is free.  That’s quite a deal. Two attorneys working on the case for perhaps 5 hours the day of the settlement conference could charge $5,000.00. The attorneys work with a judge or commissioner during the mediation. 

[Source:  LA Daily Journal 10-07-11]

Tuesday, October 04, 2011

Cheerleader Refuses to Cheer Alleged Sexual Assault Players & Is Silenced by School.

A Texas high school cheerleader claimed she was sexually assaulted during a party by two of the High School’s basketball players.  During a game that followed, the cheerleader refused to cheer for the two individuals on the team she claimed assaulted her.  The School required her to cheer, and when she refused, it removed her from the cheerleading squad.  She sued the school for retaliation and for denial of her free speech rights.

The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the dismissal of the case by the trial court, and the issue remaining was whether the School should recover its attorney’s fees and costs because the suits, according to it, were “frivolous.”  The Court held that the retaliation suit was frivolous, and that fees could be recovered.  (About $38,000.00)  The Court also held that fees were not recoverable however in the suit for denial of free speech.  The Court reasoned that a reasonable litigant could believe that the suit had merit, and that the “silent protest” of not participating as a cheerleader was a protected speech not disruptive to ordinary school functions. 

By comparison, California free speech law is more liberal and protective of students.  See Education Code Section 48950.  This section brings parity of protection for on-campus “freedom of expression” as that enjoyed by students off-campus. 

The case is:  John Doe and Jane Doe v. Silsbee Independent School District (5th Cir. 9-12-2001).