Showing posts with label law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label law. Show all posts

Monday, March 21, 2011

Colleagues: Karma and Lawyer Jokes

It seems my karma of the last 30 years is to be tracked by a series of lawyer jokes.  There is a deep cultural angst about lawyers:  we love them, hate them, hold them in high regard, and villify them.  We don't seem neutral about them. 

I confess, I am not neutral about them either.  The fact is that they are part of my professional family.  I should not be neutral.  Like any family, we are a mix of the healthy and the dysfunctional.  Becauses much of what we do is in the public eye, our flaws are all the more visible, as might be our occasional virtues.

I find reassuring that our great men, e.g., Lincoln or Adams, and our first African-American president, were first lawyers.  There is after all something good in the law, and good men seem to gravitate to it.  It is true too that scoundrels may seek to use the law for their purposes as well, but overall, it is our respect for the law, if not the the lawyers who apply it, that distinguishes us as a free people. 

On a more mundane and personal level, I like the lawyers I work with generally.  They are far and away more intelligent, more articulate, and more disciplined than many of the other people I know.  They are steadfast in their work, and dependable generally.  They are able to deal with stressful and complex situations, and reach conclusions.  The best of them are people of both heart and brain, caring deeply.  Today, for example, I worked with a lawyer on a volunteer basis who is on a committee to select speakers for our professional organization.  He took inititative, he needed little monitoring or reminding, he located and selected outstanding speakers, and he was pleasant and responsive through it all.  And, he was not unusual--this attitude and diligence is typical of the twelve members on the committee. 

If we as lawyers have a "PR problem" with the public, we probably deserve it, but not because of the failings of the majority, but the because the majority are not as visible in their virtues as the minority in their vices.  The fault is with us, as lawyers.  As a profession, we need a compelling vision of our elevated ethical and moral role in society.  We need to articulate and follow a vision of a high social calling of service, humanity, warmth, and compassion for fellow citizens.  Our essential flaw is our selfish pursuit of our own interests.  The public justly has come to distrust us if it thinks we are exploitive and abusive. 

My professional organization, the Labor and Employment Law Section of the Orange County Bar Asssociation collects and delivers food each month to a county wide food bank.  Last month we collected toys and pledges for Children's Hospital of Orange County.  As I get to know the members of the Section personally, I am discovering the goodness each of them brings to the network.  These persons are people of good character, and concern for others.  They are first persons with struggles and dreams, like us all, and then lawyers.

I think the public responds with strong negativity to lawyers at times because they want so to believe in us as "priests of the law."  We lawyers are given monopolies, with special status and opportunity.  The public justly expects us to honor our position by "good work" and "noble actions."  I can live up to that expectation.  So can my colleagues.  In fact, many of them do.  

 
"If the pink slip doesn't fit, get redressed!"
Click to see my wardrobe of remedies. Link

Friday, March 18, 2011

Sherlock Holmes Would Be Appalled: Workplace Investigations?

Federal and state statutes and case law generally anticipate that a workplace investigation is an important employer tool that will prevent discrimination and harassment, and even result in some discipline of offenders.  I'm sorry to say I have a different impression of just how these investigations actually work.  They are more often used by employers as "weapons of defense" rather than as "tools of prevention."

Federal law has long given an employer an affirmative defense that an employer is not liable for harassment which is not reported by the alleged victim [at least in cases where there has been "no tangible economic harm."].  California follows an affirmative defense of "Avoidable Consequences."  To the extent the harassment victim could have herself or himself prevented the harassment by reporting it to the employer, the employee is barred from recovery of damages for the period of non-reporting.  Bottom line:  the courts want employers to police themselves.

Instead, many Human Resource departments place their priority on creating legal documents under the direction of legal counsel. The result is an nearly inevitable conclusion of "no evidence" to support the allegations or at best, that there is "some information" of inappropriate conduct but not sufficient to find discrimination or harassment.  These findings, unsurprisingly, seem more likely to be made when the accused is high in the management hierarchy.   In my 17 years of employment law practice, I have not seen one investigation conclude that sexual harassment or other discrimination have occurred.

I really wonder what standard many so called "investigators" actually use in reaching conclusions of "no harassment.".  While proof by admissible evidence in court is not required (or desirable), it seems to me that the standard, at least in California, is whether the employer "acted reasonably" in making a decision to discipline (or forego discipline) of an accused.  That "reasonableness" standard has to be examined in the context of the legal definitions of harassment.  An investigator who does not at least know what "harassment" and "discrimination" are under the law is in a very poor position to reach conclusions.

I have had situations where my clients explain to me that they felt they were under cross-examination by the "investigator" who seemed to challenge their accusation by demanding that my client must have a direct statement by the discriminator of dislike of persons of my client's age, race, or gender.  That is not the law itself, which allows for indirect and circumstantial evidence, such as different treatment, and lack of evidence to support disciplinary action against the protected employee.

Also, many investigators seem to think that by surprising the employee with the investigation, they somehow get better, more reliable information.  Surprising an employee simply serves to get unreliable and incomplete information because the employee has not had time to recollect and organize the information.  The situation is even worse then an attorney is selected to conduct the investigation.  Then the questions seem even more adversarial.

For example, one client shared with me that the interrogator asked repeatedly:  "Is that all the information you have to support your charge of harassment?"  or  "Is there anything else you can think of that would support your charge?" or even:  "What evidence do you have that discrimination occurred?"  These are "deposition style" questions used to "lock in" a witness early to a position to prevent more information coming to light later as the employee remembers other matters.  The questions are not intended or designed to elicit all the facts impartially.   The reason the questions are unfair is that most employees do not know the legal definitions of discrimination and harassment, and think they must have direct evidence, and so will answer:  "Well, I guess that's all.  I don't know of anything else."  If you are an employee in such an "investigation" be sure to say "I may think of more later, and I will let you know," or "I felt these actions were discriminatory, and so I'm listing them all, even if you don't agree."

Another gripe of mine is that an investigation delayed is no investigation at all.  The investigation is part of a general duty to prevent discrimination and harassment, and to take prompt corrective action.  There are two goals:  protect employees from discrimination, and yes, let the harasser and others like him or her know that such conduct is punished.  I have seen many H.R. departments simply ignore or casually respond to complaints that the law requires to be promptly investigated.  The result is liability upon the employer for failure to prevent harassment or retaliation that may thereafter occur.

In conclusion, if Sherlock Holmes were asked why many workplace investigations fail to meet the requirements of the law, I suspect he would answer:  "Elementary my dear Watson."  

Tuesday, December 28, 2010

Do you own a body part or cell after it is removed by medical procedure?

This quote basically explains why I love the practice of law: 
[Moore v. Regents of the University of California (1990) 51 Cal3d Page 120, at 135]
____________________________________________

“No court, however, has ever in a reported decision imposed conversion liability for the use of human cells in medical research.*fn15 While that fact does not end our inquiry, it raises a flag of caution. (See fn. 16.) In effect, what Moore is asking us to do is to impose a tort duty on scientists to investigate the consensual pedigree of each human cell sample used in research.*fn16 To impose such a duty, which would affect medical research of importance to all of society, implicates policy concerns far removed from the traditional, two-party ownership disputes in which the law of  conversion arose.*fn17 Invoking a tort theory originally used to determine whether the loser or the finder of a horse had the better title, Moore claims ownership of the results of socially important medical research, including the genetic code for chemicals that regulate the functions of every human being's immune system.*fn18”
_______________________________________

By the way, the Supreme Court declined to recognize a continuing property interest in one’s own body parts once they are removed by medical procedures.  Thus, the Court did not extend the “Conversion” tort to cover those parts, stating that the person undergoing the procedure lost any continuing property interest on removal.  Instead, the liability, if any, the Court concluded, would arise out of a researcher’s or physician’s duty to disclose before the removal what the intended use of the body part was to be. 

© 2010 FXP
 "If the pink slip doesn't fit, get redressed!"
Click to see my wardrobe of remedies. Link

U.S. Supreme Court to Corporations: "You've Got A Lot of Nerve!" -- But Where Is It?

In my practice, a question arises from time to time:  Is this case appropriate to file in U.S. District Court?  The answer is not a matter of whim, but statutory duty:  if a defendant is resident outside the state of California, and my client (the party suing the defendant) is resident within California, and no other defendant resides in California, then the action must be filed in federal court (assuming the claim is sufficiently large).   This requirement is jurisdictional, and was originally thought necessary by Congress to avoid an out-of-state defendant being treated unfavorably by a  local court system biased in favor of its own citizens. 

Ah, but lawyers are ever parsing the meaning of seemingly plain words, such as "residency."  Where in heaven's name, is a "corporation" resident?  Where it is incorporated?  Where it does most of its business?  Where it maintains its corporate headquaters?  Where its top executives meet to run the operation?   Where oh where can my corporation be?   Plaintiff employees care about questions like these because their lawyers generally feel more comfortable in local state courts--and well they should.  The rules of evidence, the rules of pleading, and the rules of procedure are also sometimes foreign to attorneys accustomed to practicing in State courts.  Federal courts also have a nasty reputation of finding ways to dismiss employment law cases by summary judgment.  Maybe they find them somewhat parochial compared to big white collar crime or anti-trust cases.  

And so, I present this information to my readers.  The U.S. Supreme Court has elected to "brighten the line" of when "diversity of citizenship" exists where the "citizen" is a corporation.  Hint:  Look for the phrase "nerve center."  Who said corporations can't "feel"?   
 
The following was written by Michael J. Holmes
 and Heather Sullivan Riley
 Allen Matkins Leck Gamble Mallory & Natsis LLP
 San Diego Office
Source: Martindale-Hubbell
 
This decision sets out a simplified, more predictable jurisdictional rule for determining whether certain cases involving corporations that operate in multiple states can be removed to federal court. It clarifies what is often an unpredictable and expensive phase of litigation. Affected companies should review their policies and procedures in light of this decision.
 
Hertz Corp. v. Friend
 
In early 2010, the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously ruled that a corporation's "principal place of business" (i.e., where it is a citizen for jurisdictional purposes) is the place where the corporation's high level officers direct, control, and coordinate the corporation's activities - the corporation's "nerve center." Hertz Corp. v. Friend (February 23, 2010).
 
Essentially, the decision clarifies the rule concerning federal diversity jurisdiction by:
 
• Uniformly defining a corporation's "principal place of business" as the place where the corporation's activities are controlled;
 
• Limiting a corporation's "principal place of business" to only one state; and
 
• Disregarding the total amount of business activity a corporation may conduct in particular states, as well as other factors previously considered by the various circuit courts to determine a corporation's citizenship.
 
Various Tests Previously Employed By The Circuits
 
Before the Hertz decision, the circuits (and sometimes different courts within a single circuit) applied general multifactor tests in different ways to try to determine the citizenship of a corporation for diversity jurisdiction purposes. Some courts looked to where a corporation's "nerve center" was located - the place from which "it radiates out to its constituent parts and from which its officers direct, control and coordinate all activities without regard to locale." Other courts focused more heavily on where a corporation's actual business activities were located and examined a large list of factors, including, for example, plant location, sales or servicing centers, transactions, payrolls, or revenue generation. Because these tests were not uniform, a corporation's citizenship could be different depending on the circuit deciding the question. Further, the expense of determining corporate citizenship was often unnecessarily high due to the complexity and unpredictability of some of these tests.
 
The Hertz Decision: Applying The "Nerve Center" Test
 
In Hertz, two California citizens sued Hertz Corporation in state court alleging violations of California's wage and hour laws. Hertz sought to remove the case to federal court because of diversity jurisdiction. In support of their request, Hertz filed a declaration showing that although Hertz did business in California, Hertz' "principal place of business" was in New Jersey, the location of its corporate headquarters and the place where its core executive and administrative functions are carried out.
 
The District Court applied Ninth Circuit precedent that looked at the amount of a corporation's business activity state by state. Because the amount of Hertz' business activity was significantly larger in California than in other states, the District Court determined that California was Hertz' "principal place of business," and, thus, Hertz was a California citizen. The Ninth Circuit affirmed the decision, and the U.S. Supreme Court granted a writ of certiorari.
 
To address the split in the circuits and to try to simplify the jurisdictional test, the Supreme Court concluded:
 
. . . "principal place of business" is best read as referring to the place where a corporation's officers direct, control, and coordinate the corporation's activities. It is the place that Courts of Appeals have called the corporation's "nerve center." And in practice it should normally be the place where the corporation maintains its headquarters - provided that the headquarters is the actual center of direction, control, and coordination, i.e., the "nerve center," and not simply an office where the corporation holds its board meetings (for example, attended by directors and officers who have traveled there for the occasion).
 
The Supreme Court explained that this approach would avoid the complex jurisdictional tests that complicate a case, eat up time and money, produce appeals and reversals, encourage gamesmanship, waste judicial resources, and diminish the likelihood that a definite outcome can be predicted. Predictability, the Supreme Court noted, is valuable to corporations making business and investment decisions, and it benefits plaintiffs deciding whether to file in state or federal court.
 
The Supreme Court recognized, however, that the test will not always be simple. For example, in this age of video conferences, email and telecommuting, corporate officers may work at several different locations, dividing the company's command and coordinating functions. Further, a company's business activities may be very visible to the public in one state, while its top officers quietly direct those activities in another state. Such situations will require greater discovery and expense as opposed to the simpler situation addressed by Hertz.
 

"If the pink slip doesn't fit, get redressed!"
Click to see my wardrobe of remedies. Link

Monday, December 27, 2010

The Logic of Scarcity.

Here is the logic of scarcity: I hurt, therefore you should hurt too. If this is the prism by which I see the world, then I will allocate, measure, and divide according to the limitations I experience. If I am poor, I too will seek for you to be poor by my choices. In my scarcity mindset, that is only “fair” because I, that is, my ego, am the measure of what is available.

This is not abstract spirituality. This mindset plays out in jury verdicts during hard economic times when people either are unemployed or fear becoming unemployed. This “scarcity mindset” operates from the language of fear that “there is not enough.”

Now, the reality is that jurors are awarding less in damages during these difficult days. I admit that it is pure speculation on my part as to why. Any reputable social scientist would begin by asking the jurors themselves about their attitudes. Whatever the cause, my brethren in the trial bar are reporting a common trend: jurors are awarding less, and more often, awarding nothing.

The main arm of the plaintiff’s personal injury bar, the “Consumer Attorneys of California” [Note how that dirty phrase “personal injury attorney” is omitted by the name] reports that the number of personal injury cases filed has dropped 24 per cent in the last decade. Even so, trial lawyers are getting feedback from disgruntled jurors that they are more cynical, less compassionate, more withholding. Jamie Court, president of the Santa Monica based consumer rights group “Consumer Watchdog” states: “If you’re out of work and trying to find a job, why should someone who has been injured get money when you’re hurting too?”

A more systematic investigation is needed to draw reliable conclusions. Such inquiry would include some social psychology to interpret the results as well. But the reports of trial lawyers who are well known in Southern California, such as Browne Greene in Los Angeles, are that “It’s harder today for a plaintiff to get justice than it was before.” Mr. Greene also says it is harder to weed out cynical, angry jurors because the courts have reduced the time and scope of voir dire [jury selection].

The cynicism is aggravated by poorly selected cases, overreaching requests for damage awards, and delays in trial caused by overtaxed courts. People are just getting pissed off.

A good trial lawyer will feel passionately about his case, and that passion has to come through as sincerity in the presentation of the case. An excellent trial lawyer I know takes negative attitudes of jurors during voir dire, and uses them as springboards to explore why that negative attitude should not operate in his particular case. I think recent juror feedback indicates too that careful preparation, efficient use of time when qualifying documents and witnesses as evidence, and a reputable demonstration of the actual harm done to a client, will aid the trial lawyer in getting past the scarcity mindset.

Yet, I am disturbed by the logic that states that I will have less if I award you more. If that is the explanation for recent reduced jury verdicts, it does not reflect well upon the community spirit.

[Quotes are taken from the Los Angeles Daily Journal, Vol. 123, No. 249, Mon. Dec. 27, 2010, page 1]


"If the pink slip doesn't fit, get redressed!"
Click to see my wardrobe of remedies. Link

Tuesday, December 21, 2010

The Big Bananas and the Big Banana Judgment: A sadly sterile outcome.

I remember Walter Lack as a prominent attorney many years ago.  His reputation has not flagged, and he remains a "big banana" in the profession, as does his friend and occasional co-counsel Thomas Girardi.  Both of these Los Angeles based attorneys sought to enforce a half-billion dollar judgment entered by a Nicaraguan Court against Dole Food Co. The judgment mistakenly listed the defendant as "Dole Food Corporation" instead of the correct identification of "Dole Food Company".  Go figure:  Corporation vs. Company, and a half billion dollars in the balance. 

The judgment was a noble cause:  to recover damages for Nicaraguan banana workers who claimed sterility because Dole used pesticides without warning of the "family planning" implications.  Lack and Girardi came under investigation by the CA State Bar for alleged impropriety in misleading the U.S. District Court in Los Angeles that the judgment debtors were properly named:  that is, that the judgment was indeed enforceable.  The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals was upset at the alleged misrepresentation, and suspended Lack from appearing before the Court and "reprimanded" Girardi.  The State Bar however found no wrong doing, and declined to discipline either man.  After peeling away the layers on these bananas, they were found still fit for resale to the public. 

So the subtext:  two consumer rights champions making individual fortunes by taking on mega-corporations with unlimited resources to mount a defense, have a tense time before the State Bar, probably with the help of the "poor and victimized" defendant, Dole Food Company.  The big bananas almost slipped on their own peels.  Fortunately for the sterile banana workers, their tripped up advocates landed on their feet, to fight yet another day. 

"If the pink slip doesn't fit, get redressed!"
Click to see my wardrobe of remedies. Link

Friday, December 10, 2010

Let’s Face Up to Facebook Discovery: the Defense Can Discover an Employee’s Postings.

She says she was sexually harassed, but the defendant employer wants to get access to her Facebook postings because it has information that she lists herself as “single” while in truth married.  The employer asserts this is enough information to bring into question her credibility on the sexual harassment charge.  It wants a court order requiring the employee to provide password and username to access and search the site.  How will a court likely rule? 

Another way to ask this question is:  What are the employee’s reasonable privacy expectations, having filed a harassment suit against the employer.  Restrictions on the scope of the social media search are likely, but are total denial of a search legally mandated by privacy expectations? 

Let’s begin by stating that there is no definitive California a case law on this subject as yet.   The legislature has not entered the arena with specific discovery statutes aimed at social media.  Yet, some guiding principles are available.

First, the terms of agreement between the social media host and its user will be very relevant.  If the user has agreed that the posting is for full or partial public viewing, the “privacy expectation” will be determined in part by that agreement.  See Moreno v. Hanford Sentinel, Inc. (2009) 172 Cal.App.4th 1125.  In Mackelprang v. Fidelity National Title Agency of Nevade Inc. 2007 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 2379 (D. Nev. Jan. 9, 2007) the court denied an employer’s motion to compel the employee to give direct access to her MySpace account.  The facts are those stated by the opening paragraph of this  article.  The court reasoned that the “open ended” search for all MySpace positings was too broad and invasive.  It suggested a more focused description of the discoverable information. 

Discovery seeking “direct access” from the employee has a better chance of surviving a motion for protective order from the employee.  Third party access, that is, serving a subpoena on the website host itself, is unlikely of success due to federal laws generally designed to promote free use the internet.  In Crispin v. Christian Audigier Inc. 2010 U.S. Dist. Lexis 52832 (2010) the Court ruled that the Stored Communications Act (SCA) prohibited a power of subpoena to compel Facebook and MySpace to disclose plaintiff’s  private messages (non-posted, and to specific identified persons).  However, the Court remanded on the question of whether wall postings were discoverable under the SCA.  This 2010 decision, or one like it, is likely to be ultimately the subject of a published decision on the matter of SCA’s impact on the discovery of wall postings.
 
Bottom line:  the law is unsettled, but the best chance of getting social media information through formal discovery is to seek direct access and by a particularized discovery request anticipating the “privacy” objection by the employee.  Because the law is unsettled, the best approach is to enter into a stipulated restriction on the scope of search, and to agree to the confidentiality of the information except as necessary to the presentation of proof at trial or hearing. 


"If the pink slip doesn't fit, get redressed!"
Click to see my wardrobe of remedies. Link

Monday, December 06, 2010

A Class Act: Women Take on Wal-Mart by the Thousands.

So what do hundreds of thousands of women have in common at Wal-Mart?  They are class action plaintiffs proceeding in a case for gender discrimination against the retail behemoth.  The U.S. Supreme Court has accepted Wal-Mart's appeal to hear the issue of whether the class action certification was properly granted.  Among other matters, there must be an economy of disposition of the class claims because the claimants have factual and legal issues in common.  The conservative position is that they have nothing in common but their gender and that they work for Wal-Mart.  The liberal position is that they were all treated with a common systemic practice of limiting promotion and pay opportunities because they were women.  This case will decide the future of massive future class actions, and whether they will have an impact on how companies operate.  Will this one be scored for David or Goliath?  We should find out in mid 2011.  New York Times Article

"If the pink slip doesn't fit, get redressed!"
Click to see my wardrobe of remedies. Link

Friday, March 05, 2010

More Men Filing Sexual Harassment Claims

Percentage of complaints filed by men has doubled over last 20 years

By Sam Hananel
The Associated Press

updated 1:14 p.m. PT, Thurs., March. 4, 2010

WASHINGTON - Jonathan Pilkington's boss wouldn't take no for an answer.

During more than two years as a food runner at an upscale steakhouse in Scottsdale, Ariz., Pilkington says his male supervisor groped, fondled and otherwise sexually harassed him more than a dozen times.

"It was very embarrassing," Pilkington said. "I felt like I had to do something because the situation was just so bad."

Now Pilkington, a married father of two, is the star witness in a federal lawsuit against Fleming's Prime Steakhouse & Wine Bar and one of a growing number of men claiming they are victims of sexual harassment in the workplace.

From 1990 to 2009, the percentage of sexual harassment claims filed by men has doubled from 8 percent to 16 percent of all claims, according to the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.
Women still file the overwhelming majority of sexual harassment claims with the EEOC and state and local agencies. But lawyers at the commission say they've noticed the increase in complaints by men — more than 2,000 were filed in 2009 out of about 12,700 cases.

Male claims made up about 12 percent of all cases a decade ago, but the percentage has continued to rise even as the overall number of sexual harassment complaints has declined. And last year, the percentage of lawsuits the EEOC filed on behalf of male victims hit an all-time high, making up 14 percent of all cases.

"It's certainly possible that there's more sexual harassment of men going on, but it could just be that more men are coming forward and complaining about it," said Ernest Haffner, an attorney in the EEOC's Office of Legal Counsel.

While some cases allege harassment by female supervisors or co-workers, most charges involve men harassing other men. Sometimes it's unwelcome romantic advances. Other times, men are picked on because they are gay, perceived as being gay or not considered masculine enough for the work setting.
In the past, some employers might have shrugged off such antics as "boys will be boys" horseplay or fraternity-type behavior. But the EEOC has been filing more lawsuits involving male victims, saying it wants to send a message that such behavior is unacceptable and unlawful.

In November, for example, the Cheesecake Factory restaurant chain agreed to pay $345,000 to six male employees who claimed they were repeatedly sexually assaulted by a group of male kitchen staffers at a Phoenix-area restaurant.

The EEOC said the abusers would drag some victims kicking and screaming into a walk-in refrigerator, touching and grinding against the victims' genitals and take turns simulating rape. The company denied the allegations but agreed to make a financial settlement and educate its employees and managers about sexual harassment.

Susan Strauss, a consultant who advises companies about how to avoid sexual harassment in the workplace, said she's seeing more cases in which men are subject to a sexualized form of hazing.
"If you don't fit the masculine stereotype or are viewed as effeminate, you get picked on in a sexual way to demean you," Strauss said.

Cases involving women making unwanted advances toward men may also be rising as women make up a growing part of the work force. Last year, the Regal Entertainment Group, which operates a national chain of movie theaters, agreed to pay $175,000 to settle a lawsuit by a male employee who claimed a female co-worker repeatedly grabbed his crotch at work.

When the employee complained to his supervisor and the theater's then-general manager, he claims, she failed to stop the harassment and instead retaliated against the victim with unfair discipline and lower performance evaluations.

The number of cases filed by men has grown steadily since a landmark Supreme Court ruling in 1998 held that same-sex harassment is a valid claim under federal anti-discrimination laws. That ruling involved an offshore oil rig worker who said he was subject to humiliating sex-related treatment by other workers, including being sodomized in the shower with a bar of soap.

In Pilkington's case, he claims the restaurant's chef would grope and pinch his genitals or grab his backside when Pilkington walked to the kitchen or stock room. Despite his complaints to the restaurant's operating partner, he says the conduct didn't stop.

After one incident, Pilkington lost his composure and yelled at the chef, making a scene. Days later, he was fired — an action he claims was retaliation for his complaints. An EEOC lawsuit on behalf of Pilkington and three other current and former employees is pending.

"I think maybe it's just harder for males to come out and file a complaint because of how embarrassing it is," Pilkington said. "When I talk about it I get this nauseous feeling in my stomach."

The restaurant has denied the charges. In a statement, the company that owns Fleming's said the restaurant "has always been committed to providing a safe and healthy workplace free of harassment for all of its associates."

Many victims are hesitant to come forward because they are afraid of being considered unmanly or being derided by co-workers, said Mary Jo O'Neill, a regional attorney in the EEOC's Phoenix District office.

"All sexual harassment victims feel humiliated, lacking control and power," O'Neill said. "This has a different twist because everyone expects that they would be able to handle it and take care of it themselves."

Pilkington has since moved on to another job. While he is embarrassed by the publicity his case has received, he says it was the right thing to do. The EEOC lawsuit seeks damages for him and other workers alleging harassment, along with back pay and compensatory and punitive damages.


© 2010 MSNBC.com

"If the pink slip doesn't fit,
get redressed!"
Click to see my wardrobe of remedies.
Link

Most Stressful Jobs


Taken from MSNBC:

FIRST:  Surgeons top the list of most stressful jobs because their work can be physically demanding, require meeting tough deadlines and involve life or death situations.

By the way, the least stressful jobs are actuary, dietitian, computer systems analyst, statistician, astronomer, mathematician, historian, and software engineer, according to CareerCast.

The jobs included in the ranking can change annually depending on Surgeons have to stay on their feet for long hours at a time and often have many people dependent upon them.

That goes for surgeons who work in small-town hospitals as well as in big cities.

SECOND:  Few events can ever be as stressful as trying to land a plane full of passengers safely in the Hudson River after a bird strike. That explains why pilots like Chesley Burnett "Sully" Sullenberger, at left in cockpit, rank second on the list.

Pilots generally have only one chance to correctly take off and land each flight, and the lives of often more than 100 passengers hang in the balance.
"They have to handle fairly sophisticated technology," Lee said, adding that they have to ready to react at a moment's notice. "Their jobs can be quiet and unstressful for long periods of time and then suddenly it can be the most stressful job on earth."


http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/34114804/ns/business-careers

"If the pink slip doesn't fit,
get redressed!"
Click to see my wardrobe of remedies.

Link

Monday, January 11, 2010

High court pulls plug on YouTube trial coverage

High court pulls plug on YouTube trial coverage


EXCERPT: The court said it wanted until at least Wednesday to consider arguments by backers of Proposition 8, the November 2008 ballot measure outlawing same-sex marriage, that camera coverage could result in threats or even violence against witnesses favoring the measure.


EXCERPT: Trial on YouTube?

-- What happened: The Supreme Court issued a stay through Wednesday on a judge's plans to allow the trial over California's same-sex marriage ban to be uploaded to YouTube.

-- What's next: The court wants to hear more arguments on the issue. It could then lift its stay or make the camera ban permanent.

-- How to watch the trial: Thirty-six seats are available to the public in the courtroom of Chief U.S. District Judge Vaughn Walker on the 17th floor of the federal courthouse, 450 Golden Gate Avenue in San Francisco. Another 150 seats are available in an overflow room on the 19th floor in which the trial is being shown on closed-circuit TV.

Chronicle staff writer Bob Egelko contributed to this report. E-mail the writers at jvanderbeken@sfchronicle.com and jgarofoli@sfchronicle.com.



"If the pink slip doesn't fit,
get redressed!"
Click to see my wardrobe of remedies.


Link

Tuesday, November 10, 2009

Dear Union: "Do me no favors!"

Dear Union: "Do me no favors!" Unions that explicitly include discrimination in their list of covered disputes to be resolved by Arbitration clauses found in their collective bargaining agreements are not necessarily helping their membership. The reality is that weak unions fail to carry the cases of their membership through the grievance exhaustion process necessary to get to arbitration, with the result that major rights are lost. The Supreme Court has rather dismissively stated that the employee who thus loses his rights against the employer can then pursue a "Failure of Duty of Fair Representation" against the Union. This cause of action is virtually non-existent for a number of reasons, one of which is the high standard of proof imposed on the employee, and the other is the lack of an attorney fees provision for the prevailing employee. If you are a Union employee, and realize how lax your Union generally is in "fighting back", discourage your Union leadership from including discrimination in its list of violations included within the scope of your collective bargaining agreement.

To read more about the recent U.S. Supreme Court case on this point: